Ingredients: (makes 18)
1 cup graham cracker crumbs (15 squares)
pinch of cinnamon
4 tablespoons (1/2 stick) butter, melted
16 ounces (2 blocks) cream cheese, softened
1 cup sugar
3 large eggs
1 pint (16 ounces) sour cream
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
food coloring – pink, purple, blue, green, yellow, and red
stand mixer or a mixing bowl and hand held mixer
3 Wilton Heart Shaped Silicone Molds
fine tip paint brush (new or food only brush)
roasting pan big enough to fit your heart shaped molds
Preheat oven to 325 degrees.
You will need a water bath to bake your cheesecakes, so either place your roasting pan in the oven filled with enough water to go half way up the sides of your heart molds and allow the water to heat along with the oven or bring some water to a boil in a tea pot or the microwave.
A little trick I use – my roasting pan has a flat rack with handles that fit inside. I set my two heart molds on the rack, so that later I can simply lower the rack along with the filled heart molds into the hot water in the roasting pan.
mini heart cheesecakes
Combine graham cracker crumbs, cinnamon, and melted butter, stirring until it looks like sand. (I used my food processor to grind the graham crackers, then I added the cinnamon and butter and pulsed it until well combined.)
Spoon out about a tablespoon of crumb mixture into each heart cavity. Press the crumbs down making an even crust. Refrigerate until ready to fill with cheesecake mixture.
Note: Being I only made 12 cheesecakes with crusts, I had some of this leftover.
best cheesecake recipe
In the bowl of a stand mixer, or in a mixing bowl using a hand held mixer, beat the cream cheese on medium high until smooth, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Be sure to scrape the cream cheese out of the mixing blade as well. You don’t want lumps in your cheesecake.
Add sugar and beat for one minute. Add eggs and beat until creamy, 1 to 2 minutes, scraping the sides of the bowl once. Add the sour cream and vanilla and mix just to combine.
conversation heart cheesecake recipe
Equally divide the filling among 6 bowls. Add food coloring to create the colors you’d like.
It took between five and eight drops of color to achieve the colors of my cakes. For orange, mix yellow and red together.
how to make conversation heart cheesecakes
Pour colored cheesecake filling into the heart shaped cavities in your Wilton silicone mold. If you are using 3 heart molds and making 18 cheesecakes, equally divide each color among 3 hearts. The cavities will be a little less than completely full.
I filled mine completely, as I only made 12 of this size. I then used the remaining batter to make some mini hearts (see image below.)
I made pink, lavender, yellow, orange, green, and blue hearts, but have to say the blue was awful looking once baked. I would either go lighter next time, or just make a few white hearts.
baking conversation heart cheesecakes
Bake cheesecakes in a water bath for 22-25 minutes, if making 18 hearts.
When baked thoroughly, the cheesecakes should still jiggle, but not look soupy.
I set my heart molds on a flat rack, which made it so easy to move and lower into the roasting pan which was already filled with water that had heated up while the oven was pre-heating.
You can set your heart molds in your roasting pan, then carefully pour boiling water around the heart molds. Just fill up the pan so that the water goes half way up the sides of the heart mold.
My tiny cheesecakes baked for 15 minutes.
If hearts are completely filled, bake for 26-28 minutes. I baked my cakes 30 minutes (I got distracted and didn’t check them when I should have.) They developed a bit of a skin on top, but really were perfect inside.
If you bake one large cheesecake, it should take about 45 minutes.
mini conversation heart cheesecakes
Remove your baked cheesecakes and allow to cool at room temperature for an hour. The minis will probably cool in about 30 minutes.
wilton silicone heart mold conversation heart cheesecakes
Freeze the cheesecakes for at least 2 hours, and up to several weeks. Remove from freezer and push on the underside of each heart, releasing the cheesecakes. Carefully lift them out of the mold. If they don’t pop right out, you need to freeze them longer. I only broke off a tiny piece of crust from one of my hearts after allowing them to freeze for two hours.
Notes: My frozen hearts did have beads of condensation on them when I took them out of the freezer, but they dried after refrigerating them for a while. Of course you don’t want to serve them frozen, so you’ll need to allow them to warm up a bit before serving.
decorate conversation heart cheesecakes
To add the conversation heart phrases, squeeze a few drops of red food coloring into a small bowl. Use a fine tip paintbrush to paint the words onto each cheesecake heart.
Traditional conversation heart sayings are printed in all capital letters.
Don’t worry if your words are off center, as many conversation hearts are printed that way.
If you have too much food coloring on your brush, your letters will bleed.
The food coloring will dry if you refrigerate your cheesecakes for a while.
Store in the refrigerator for up to several days or freeze for up to a month.
I suggest storing them in an airtight container. To keep the condensation from developing on the tops of the cheesecakes, set a piece of paper towel, that is larger than the container’s lid, across the underside of the lid. Close and seal. The moisture will get wicked up by the paper towel.
If you’d prefer a naturally colored version of this Conversation Heart Cheesecake recipe, check out my tutorial and recipe for heart cheesecakes colored using fruits and vegetables